MindRomp Forum

MindRomp Forum (http://mindromp.org/forum/index.php)
-   Mafia (http://mindromp.org/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=17)
-   -   Mafia Parody - Day 3 (http://mindromp.org/forum/showthread.php?t=3663)

Magicziggy 14th May 2018 03:34 AM

VT in role madness does not ping as much as you thinking it's an issue.

sparking 14th May 2018 04:04 AM

:shockcorn: holy fucking cow

what part of we are confirmed do you not get?

sparking 14th May 2018 04:42 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sparking (Post 429424)
:shockcorn: holy fucking cow

what part of we are confirmed do you not get?

cory on our hydra chat: "all of it"

charlou 14th May 2018 04:44 AM

I really think longhair has played a smooth as silk scum game.

Magicziggy 14th May 2018 04:48 AM

For me it's a 3 way conundrum.

To believe Charlou is a sane or naive seer in this setup. Coupled with her play and the overall mechanics, this is believable.

To believe Longhair is a vt in this set up. Coupled with his play this is believable.

To believe there is a doc/vig. Yep I get that.
To believe you vigged bor. Tick.
To believe you docced me over op8, starts to break down here.
And your play has been about playing on the whole Hydra thing. Giving an out to vote for absolutely anyone.

So now we have to say how can you be doc/vig? I said day 1 that flavour of roles was important. And what's missing is the criminal element. The role thief.

Here's the killer piece of evidence.

Borealis as bullet proof makes absolutely no sense as a town role when the scum kill is not by bullet. Borealis and you have swapped roles. Scum had bulletproof and town has death proof. Town never had both.

Charlou and Longhair please indicate that you have at least read and understood my argument as to why sparking is the last Scum. when I get a chance I'll see if I can find a role that fits.

charlou 14th May 2018 04:52 AM

My role pm states I'm sane cop, and that other roles might mean I get an incorrect result.

I'll look at your argument properly after work, mz

Magicziggy 14th May 2018 04:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by charlou (Post 429427)
I really think longhair has played a smooth as silk scum game.

You think he tried to bus rach day 1?
Then pulled away when she claimed.

You think his consistent stance with Mantis was because he knew what she was going to flip?

If you believe this, then you are buying that scum had a negative role (usurper) and town had bullet proof and death proof.

sparking 14th May 2018 04:52 AM

charlou as naive seer was something me and diva discussed

as for the rest of your "killer case"

:twitch::twitch::twitch::twitch::twitch:

- c

longhair75 14th May 2018 04:52 AM

I do see what you are thinking, and it makes sense

Magicziggy 14th May 2018 04:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by charlou (Post 429429)
My role pm states I'm sane cop, and that other roles might mean I get an incorrect result.

I'll look at your argument properly after work, mz

Designed to create today's mislynch.

longhair75 14th May 2018 04:53 AM

the above is in response to MZ

sparking 14th May 2018 04:53 AM

i don't want to live in this village anymore

- cory

charlou 14th May 2018 04:54 AM

B was killed n2. N2 sparking viewed as "innocent"

longhair75 14th May 2018 04:55 AM

I am off to bed.. I have an early start tomorrow, and will have access for a while. I will be out of touch through most of the work day. no electronic devices allowed in the County Jail

charlou 14th May 2018 04:56 AM

Later guys

sparking 14th May 2018 04:59 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by charlou (Post 429436)
B was killed n2. N2 sparking viewed as "innocent"

i am trying to understand living in a world where it is more plausible that we're the non-flip changing role thief mafia don strongman kill is more plausible than lh lying about being VT

unless MZ is arguing we were originally 2x bulletproof and "flipped roles" with bor who was the doc, which doesn't account for the fact of a necessary strongman modifier according to his theory, but i imagine he's just ignoring that hole so his hard-on for pushing diva can continue

- c

sparking 14th May 2018 05:00 AM

my first mindromp experience has truly delivered

charlou 14th May 2018 05:04 AM

I think I'll be dead tonight, but atm my vote would be longhair. I expect he'll kill me to increase his chance of surviving day four.

We shall see :l

charlou 14th May 2018 05:04 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sparking (Post 429440)
my first mindromp experience has truly delivered

:hug:

sparking 14th May 2018 05:11 AM

you do understand we cleared because of mechanics, right?

we know that there is a doc because a nurse flipped. a nurse's role does not activate until the doc dies.

we are uncc-ed.

I don't need an argument the 2 statements are facts that we know because spruce is saying it in the op and spruce does not put superfluous roles in the game.

I have no words. no words.

Magicziggy 14th May 2018 05:22 AM

OK, I'll do a full reset.

If longhair is scum I have to pinpoint the number of times he has done a scum move as opposed to just rolling along with the game as he usually does. For example voting rach.

Also if sparking is doc, potential to save a kill.

Magicziggy 14th May 2018 05:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sparking (Post 429443)
you do understand we cleared because of mechanics, right?

we know that there is a doc because a nurse flipped. a nurse's role does not activate until the doc dies.

we are uncc-ed.

I don't need an argument the 2 statements are facts that we know because spruce is saying it in the op and spruce does not put superfluous roles in the game.

I have no words. no words.

There has to be a time where I accept that. And if it were any other way then the mechanics cannot be fathomed.

Magicziggy 14th May 2018 05:26 AM

I'm thinking that scum may have lynch proof up their sleeve.
Town has 2x bulletproof and death proof (unused, conditional and limited)

Magicziggy 14th May 2018 05:33 AM

The thought of longhair being scum doesn't bare thinking about.

Jiffy would have been right :christyes::staregonk:

Magicziggy 14th May 2018 05:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by charlou (Post 429427)
I really think longhair has played a smooth as silk scum game.

I'm here :gun:


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 01:47 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2018, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Copyright 2011-2018 MindRomp.org