Links
Portal |  Forum | Core Values | 
MindRomp Forum  

FAQ Janitors Arcade
Go Back   MindRomp Forum > Community > Mafia

Mafia 8/10 of Mafia GMs who expressed a preference, prefer Mindromp

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 1st October 2012, 04:53 PM   #67471  /  #26
Cpt. Gender Injustice
I Was Banned, But...
 
Cpt. Gender Injustice's Avatar
 

no updates here?
__________________
Cpt. Gender Injustice is offline   Reply With Quote topbottom
Old 1st October 2012, 09:44 PM   #67508  /  #27
Adenosine
Needs essential amino acids
 
Adenosine's Avatar
 

Read my posts with the following stupid accent: Australia
My bad. I'll sit down and have a look through tonight.
Adenosine is offline   Reply With Quote topbottom
Old 1st October 2012, 10:03 PM   #67517  /  #28
spruce
redolent needling balm
 
spruce's Avatar
 

Read my posts with the following stupid accent: Appalachia, CSA
I've just about got it done, Aden, but with a few role holes.
spruce is offline   Reply With Quote topbottom
Old 1st October 2012, 10:04 PM   #67518  /  #29
spruce
redolent needling balm
 
spruce's Avatar
 

Read my posts with the following stupid accent: Appalachia, CSA
Game 7 – Fairy Tale Mafia

Game 7 – GM Linus – 24/12, 2 days, no night chat
01. ksen
02. borealis (M (Knight in Shining Armour) 1-2)
03. gib
04. daphne – Big Bad Wolf, scum, Day 1 'lynch'
05. aden
06. fuzzy – Evil Queen, scum 1-shot double-voter, Day 2 'lynch'
07. jerome
08 charlou
09. ronan
10. amok
11. Zigmen - Fairy Godmother, Town Seer, N1 kill by poison apple

Town wins!
spruce is offline   Reply With Quote topbottom
Old 1st October 2012, 10:05 PM   #67519  /  #30
spruce
redolent needling balm
 
spruce's Avatar
 

Read my posts with the following stupid accent: Appalachia, CSA
Game 8 - Scooby-Doo Mafia

Game 8 – GM Daphne Girl/oblivion – 24/12 - 5 days, no night chat

01. Aden – vanilla Town
02. Borealis – Horton Doo, Town Doctor, N1 'kill'
03. Linus – 10,000 Volt Ghost, Scum Roleblocker, Day 5 'lynch'
04. Zigmen – Ghost of Captain Cutler, vanilla Scum, D4 'lynch'
05. gib (M) – vanilla Town
06. mantis – Daphne Blake, Town Blocker, N4 'kill'
07. ronan – D2 no-lynch, Miner 49er, Scum Silencer, N2 'kill'
08. jerome – Town Investigator
09. praying – vanilla Town
10. el guapo verdadero – Scooby-Doo, vanilla Town, D3 'lynch'
11. Bobby Arthur
12. ksen – Fred Jones, vanilla Town, N3 'kill'
13. Charlou – Scrappy-Doo, Indie Jack-of-all-trades
14. Diva – vanilla Town
15. MZ – Gramps the Vamp, Scum Don, Day 1 'lynch'
16. Nightson – vanilla Town
17. Amok – Uncle Karl

Town wins!
spruce is offline   Reply With Quote topbottom
Old 1st October 2012, 10:07 PM   #67520  /  #31
spruce
redolent needling balm
 
spruce's Avatar
 

Read my posts with the following stupid accent: Appalachia, CSA
Game 9 – Asylum Mafia (2 play 1) (Writeboard crisis)

Game 9 – GM Adenosine – 4 days, night chat

Dan B - charlou – chardan – Scum Psychiatrist, N3 kill
praying - spruce – spraying (M 3-4)– 1-shot Town Vig turned Indie SK Sole-survivor
gib - Daphne Girl - gibne Girl – killed and eaten D4 by Spraying
Zigmen - Jerome – Zigerome – Town Blocker, D2 lynch
borealis - Gonzo – bonzo – vanilla Town, N3 kill
UselessTwit - Mantisdreamz – MantisTwit – vanilla Town, D1 lynch
nick - Ronan – Ronick – Scum Roleblocker, D3 lynch
Bobby Arthur - divagreen – divvybby – Town Seer, N1 kill
MagicZiggy - Amok - Magamok (M 1-2) – vanilla Town, N2 kill

Spraying Sole-survivor SK wins!
spruce is offline   Reply With Quote topbottom
Old 1st October 2012, 10:07 PM   #67521  /  #32
spruce
redolent needling balm
 
spruce's Avatar
 

Read my posts with the following stupid accent: Appalachia, CSA
Game 10 – Divorce Court Mafia

Game 10 – GM Bobby Arthur – 24/12, 4 days, no night chat

01. divagreen – Town Reporter
02. borealis – Psycho divorced mom, Scum whore, D3 lynch
03. jerome – Town kid
04. gib - happily married Town
05. Adenosine - Scum
06. Ksen – Town kid
07. Dan – lawyer, Town Doc
08. Oblivion (M) – Town kid
09. Amok – European grandmother, Indie SK survivor, N1 kill
10. Mantis – Town kid
11. guapo – Judge, corrupt Town Seer
12. Ronan/Spruce – family woman, vanilla Town
13. Daphne – Town Miller
14. charlou – family man, vanilla Town, D1 lynch
15. Rockatansky/Zigmen – Gold-digging mom, Scum
16. MagicZiggy CPS Worker, Town Seer, N2 kill

Town wins!

Last edited by spruce; 1st October 2012 at 11:05 PM. Reason: gib half-role
spruce is offline   Reply With Quote topbottom
Old 1st October 2012, 10:08 PM   #67522  /  #33
spruce
redolent needling balm
 
spruce's Avatar
 

Read my posts with the following stupid accent: Appalachia, CSA
Game 11 – Garden Mafia

Game 11 – GM Jerome – 24/12, 5 days, night chat

01. Bobby – purple coneflower, Town Seer, N3 kill
02. Amok – astilbe, Town Doc, N4 kill
03. Daphne – siberian iris, Town
04. Borealis – threadleaf tickseed, Town
05. Mantis – milkweed, Scum
06. Ksen – silver grass, vanilla town, D4 lynch
07. Gib – creeping jenny. Scum Don
08. Spruce – yarrow, vanilla town, N2 kill
09. Gonzo – speedwell, vanilla Town, D1 lynch
10. MZ – ground ivy (creeping charlie), Scum Blocker, D3 lynch
11. Nostrum – blanket flower, N1 kill
12. Longhair – peonies, vanilla Town, D2 lynch

Scum wins!
spruce is offline   Reply With Quote topbottom
Old 1st October 2012, 10:09 PM   #67524  /  #34
spruce
redolent needling balm
 
spruce's Avatar
 

Read my posts with the following stupid accent: Appalachia, CSA
Game 12 – Red Dwarf Mafia

Game 12 – GM oblivion – 24/12, 6 days, no night chat

01 chaoschristian – Psiren, Scum Roleblocker, N1 kill
02. MSG/borealis – Holly, backup Town Seer – N2 kill
03. charlou – Scutter 1, Town Mason, N2 kill
04. magicziggy – Rimmer, Lynchee, N4 kill
05. nostradammit/Mantis – Chocolate Dispenser, Lyncher turned Traitor
06. SR – Mr. Flibble, vanilla Town
07. Amok – Revolving Toilet, vanilla Town, D4 lynch
08. ksen – Kryten, Town Doc
09. longhair – Duane Dibley, vanilla Town, D2 lynch
10. Danny – Red Dwarf Data, Indie SK, D3 lynch
11. Contrapposto – Cat, Town Hobo 'Seer', N3 kill
12. divagreen (M) – Polymorph, Scum Don/Roleblocker
13. spruce – Scutter 2, Town Mason, N! kill
14. Ronan – Katarina Bartikovsky, vanilla Town, D5 lynch
15. nick – Despair Squid, Scum Silencer, D1 lynch
16. r.c – Ace Rimmer, vanilla Town / converts to Vengeful Town if Rimmer dies

Scum Win! Mantis Traitor Win!
spruce is offline   Reply With Quote topbottom
Old 1st October 2012, 10:10 PM   #67525  /  #35
spruce
redolent needling balm
 
spruce's Avatar
 

Read my posts with the following stupid accent: Appalachia, CSA
Game 13 – Footrot Flats Mafia

Game 13 – GM MSG – 6 days, no night chat

01. Jerome/r.c - Murphys' croco-pig, vanilla Scum – D3 lynch
02. MZ – Dog, Town Flavour Cop, N4 kill
03. Borealis – Jess, vanilla Town
04. Amok – Cooch's Cousin Kathy, vanilla Town, N2 Vig kill
05. Longhair75 – Aunt Dolly, Town Seer, D5 lynch
06. gib (M) - Major the pigdog, Town
07. charlou - Cream Puff Murphy, vanilla Scum, N3 Vig kill
08. ksen/divagreen – Cecil the Ram, vanilla Town
09. spruce – Horse, Town Vig
10. nick - Elvis "Spit" Murphy, vanilla Scum, D4 lynch
11. Contrapposto – Boris the Boar, vanilla Town, N1 Scum kill
12. SR71 – Cheeky Hobson, vanilla Town, N1 Vig kill
13. Ronan - Stewart "Irish" Murphy, Scum Don, N5 Vig kill
14. Adenosine – Rangi Jones, vanilla Town, D2 lynch
15. Nostrum – Wal Footrot, vanilla Town, D1 lynch
16. Bobby Arthur – Cooch Windgrass, Town Jailer, N5 kill

Town Wins!

Last edited by spruce; 1st October 2012 at 11:14 PM. Reason: gib half-role
spruce is offline   Reply With Quote topbottom
Old 1st October 2012, 10:11 PM   #67527  /  #36
spruce
redolent needling balm
 
spruce's Avatar
 

Read my posts with the following stupid accent: Appalachia, CSA
Game 14 – Cancer Mafia

Game 14 – GM Adenosine – 24/12, 5 days, night chat

01) Longhair – Indie SK
02) Diva – Caspase-3, Town Vigilante, out N1
03) Magicziggy – Dreadlocks, vanilla Town, N2 kill
04) Amok (M 5)
05) charlou – Sonic hedgehog, Town Traitor, D1 lynch
06) SR71 – Gonadoliberin, vanilla Town, D5 lynch
07) nick – Smoothened, vanilla Town, D3 lynch
08) borealis – Dishevelled, vanilla Town, N4 kill
09) gib – p53, Town Cop, N2 kill
10) Supernaut/Spruce – Wee1, vanilla Town, N3 kill
11) Ironclad - VT
12) Zigmen – Stattic, vanilla Town, N1 kill
13) oblivion - Scum
14) MSG (M 1-4) – Wrenchnolol, Town Roleblocker, N4 kill
15) Mantisdreamz – VEGFR-2, Scum Recruiter, D2 lynch
16) r.c – MAP-kinase-kinase-kinase, vanilla Town, N3 kill
17) ksen – teashirt grunge, vanilla Town, D4 lynch
18) Free Falling - Scum

Scum Wins! Longhair75 SK Wins! charlou Traitor Wins!

Last edited by spruce; 1st October 2012 at 11:22 PM.
spruce is offline   Reply With Quote topbottom
Old 1st October 2012, 10:12 PM   #67528  /  #37
spruce
redolent needling balm
 
spruce's Avatar
 

Read my posts with the following stupid accent: Appalachia, CSA
Game 15 – Flavorless Mafia – open game setup

Game 15 – GM Linus – 24/12, 4 days, no night chat

01. borealis (M 1) – Kaka, Town Seer, N1 'kill'
02. MagicZiggy – Cristiano Ronaldo, Town Vig/Bomb, N1 'kill'
03. Ironclad – Barrack Obama, vanilla Town, N3 'kill'
04. Kazaman/Jerome – Rihanna, vanilla Town, D3 'lynch' again
05. longhair
06. spruce – Britney Spears, Town Miller, N2 'kill'
07. jerome – Snoop Dogg, vanilla Town, D1 'lynch'
08. Zigmen – Selena Gomes, vanilla Town, D4 lynch
09. Bobby – Shakira, vanilla Town, D3 'kill'
10. Teshi – Scum Role Cop
11. Danny
12. Charlou
13. gib (M 2) Scum Poisoner
14. Amok – Lady Gaga, vanilla Town, D2 'lynch'
15. Godless Infidel – vanilla Scum

Sum Wins!
spruce is offline   Reply With Quote topbottom
Old 1st October 2012, 10:15 PM   #67531  /  #38
spruce
redolent needling balm
 
spruce's Avatar
 

Read my posts with the following stupid accent: Appalachia, CSA
^ Like I said, there's a few holes in the above,

And I'm not quite sure just how we prefer to tally. Right now I've got it thus:

Town – 7 (Gm 3, 4, 7, 8, 10, 13)
Scum – 6.5 (Gm 1, 2, 6, 11, 12, 14, 15)
Jester – 1 (Gm 1)
Traitor – 3 (Gm 2, 12, 14)
Cult – 1 (Gm 5)
SK – 2 (Gm 9, 14)
Sole-survivor – 1 (Gm 9)

Last edited by spruce; 1st October 2012 at 11:23 PM.
spruce is offline   Reply With Quote topbottom
Old 1st October 2012, 10:30 PM   #67534  /  #39
Adenosine
Needs essential amino acids
 
Adenosine's Avatar
 

Read my posts with the following stupid accent: Australia
Thanks Spruce. Awesome work. I'll have a bone for you later.

Not like that, you dirty bastards.

Quote:
Originally Posted by spruce View Post
^ Like I said, there's a few holes in the above,

And I'm not quite sure just how we prefer to tally. Right now I've got it thus:

Town – 7 (Gm 3, 4, 7, 8, 10, 13)
Scum – 6.5 (Gm 1, 2, 6, 11, 12, 14, 15)
Jester – 1 (Gm 1)
Traitor – 2 (Gm 2, 12)
Cult – 1 (Gm 5)
SK – 2 (Gm 9, 14)
Sole-survivor – 1 (Gm 9)
I like that format too. Mind if I C&P that into the OP?
Adenosine is offline   Reply With Quote topbottom
Old 1st October 2012, 10:32 PM   #67536  /  #40
spruce
redolent needling balm
 
spruce's Avatar
 

Read my posts with the following stupid accent: Appalachia, CSA
Bone first, clip later.
spruce is offline   Reply With Quote topbottom
Old 1st October 2012, 10:36 PM   #67537  /  #41
borealis
poikilothermic
 
borealis's Avatar
 

Read my posts with the following stupid accent: Canada
Quote:
Originally Posted by spruce View Post
Bone first, clip later.
Smart puppy.
__________________
borealis is offline   Reply With Quote topbottom
Old 2nd October 2012, 04:19 AM   #67597  /  #42
spruce
redolent needling balm
 
spruce's Avatar
 

Read my posts with the following stupid accent: Appalachia, CSA
Game 16 – Tortured Artist Mafia

Game 16 – GM Teshi – 24/12, no night chat

01. borealis - Hieronymus Bosch, vanilla Town, N1 shamed
02. Adenosine - Oleg Kulik, Town two-shot Vigilante, N2 kill
03. divagreen - William Kurelek, vanilla Town, D4 schizophrenic middle school art teachered
04. Kazaman - Adolf Hitler, vanilla scum, N2 'kill'
05. r.c – Kurt Coban, vanilla Town
06. praying - Anne Sexton, vanilla Town, D3 shamed
07. Jerome – Virginia Dire Woolf, vanilla Town, D1 'lynch'
08. Amok – Carlo Gesualdo, two-shot Commuter Scum
09. Godless Infidel – Edgar Allan Poe, Town Tracker
10. Daphne - Francisco Goya, vanilla Town, D2 'lynch'
11. Contrapposto - Henri de Toulouse-Lautrec (dwarf), Town Watcher, N1 kill
12. Aletheia - Charles Baudelaire, vanilla Town, D5 consumptiated
13. Evolving - Fyodor Dostoyevsky, vanilla Town, N4 kill
14. Mantisdreamz – Sid Vicious, vanilla Scum
15. spruce - Mikhail “The Wolf” Lermontov, Town Doc, N3 shamed
16. SR71 (M 1-5) Wesley Willis, two-shot town vig, N5 kill
17. chaoschristian - Richard Dadd, Scum Follower, N4 bricked to death
18. gib - Yukio Mishima, Town two-shot Vigilante, N3 bricked to death

Scum Wins!
spruce is offline   Reply With Quote topbottom
Old 2nd October 2012, 04:22 AM   #67600  /  #43
spruce
redolent needling balm
 
spruce's Avatar
 

Read my posts with the following stupid accent: Appalachia, CSA
Scum – 7.5 (Gm 1, 2, 6, 11, 12, 14, 15, 16)
Town – 7 (Gm 3, 4, 7, 8, 10, 13)
Traitor – 3 (Gm 2, 12, 14)
SK – 2 (Gm 9, 14)
Jester – 1 (Gm 1)
Cult – 1 (Gm 5)
Sole-survivor – 1 (Gm 9)

With Game 16, Scum have a trifecta and 5 out of the last 6. MR Town needs some work.
spruce is offline   Reply With Quote topbottom
Old 2nd October 2012, 09:00 AM   #67621  /  #44
Adenosine
Needs essential amino acids
 
Adenosine's Avatar
 

Read my posts with the following stupid accent: Australia
Where did the 0.5 come from?
Adenosine is offline   Reply With Quote topbottom
Old 2nd October 2012, 11:45 AM   #67633  /  #45
spruce
redolent needling balm
 
spruce's Avatar
 

Read my posts with the following stupid accent: Appalachia, CSA
Game #1, where the Jester actually won the game, but scum gained a second place finish. What do you think, is that the best way to judge it?
spruce is offline   Reply With Quote topbottom
Old 2nd October 2012, 12:30 PM   #67635  /  #46
Adenosine
Needs essential amino acids
 
Adenosine's Avatar
 

Read my posts with the following stupid accent: Australia
Quote:
Originally Posted by spruce View Post
Game #1, where the Jester actually won the game, but scum gained a second place finish. What do you think, is that the best way to judge it?
My opinion is no. I know that most TR players discount a jester win and only count a town or scum win. But I think that discounts the jester role.

I think we need to give jesters the wins they deserve.

This will do two things in short order.

The rest of the players will stop killing them quickly and jesters will have to get clever about it.

What does everyone else think?
Adenosine is offline   Reply With Quote topbottom
Old 2nd October 2012, 12:33 PM   #67636  /  #47
divagreen
Senior Member
 
divagreen's Avatar
 

IMO, the game is between and town. indies who meet their win condition win with scum or town. the only indie win condition that wins the game on their own is a sole survivor.
__________________
divagreen is offline   Reply With Quote topbottom
Old 2nd October 2012, 12:51 PM   #67637  /  #48
chaoschristian
Righteous Thrasher
 
chaoschristian's Avatar
 

Quote:
Originally Posted by Adenosine View Post
Quote:
Originally Posted by spruce View Post
Game #1, where the Jester actually won the game, but scum gained a second place finish. What do you think, is that the best way to judge it?
My opinion is no. I know that most TR players discount a jester win and only count a town or scum win. But I think that discounts the jester role.

I think we need to give jesters the wins they deserve.

This will do two things in short order.

The rest of the players will stop killing them quickly and jesters will have to get clever about it.

What does everyone else think?
Doesn't determination of victory depend on what the GM says the victory conditions are?

So, if the GM includes a jester with X victory conditions and the jester player fulfills those conditions, then that player wins a victory.

It doesn't matter what we think should be the outcomes, and it's not a matter of shoehorning this into some neat model.

If the GM says borealis's VC is to survive past N1 and also win with town, then if she does, borealis scores two distinct victories.
chaoschristian is offline   Reply With Quote topbottom
Old 2nd October 2012, 12:52 PM   #67638  /  #49
spruce
redolent needling balm
 
spruce's Avatar
 

Read my posts with the following stupid accent: Appalachia, CSA
LOL, so I'm still guessing maybe it is the fairest way - Jester got 1 in the win column, and Scum got a .5 for second place. Let others weigh in, but that seemed to be what that particular GM indicated, right?
spruce is offline   Reply With Quote topbottom
Old 2nd October 2012, 01:44 PM   #67647  /  #50
Adenosine
Needs essential amino acids
 
Adenosine's Avatar
 

Read my posts with the following stupid accent: Australia
Quote:
Originally Posted by divagreen View Post
IMO, the game is between and town. indies who meet their win condition win with scum or town. the only indie win condition that wins the game on their own is a sole survivor.
And jesters, by definition.

Quote:
Originally Posted by chaoschristian View Post
Quote:
Originally Posted by Adenosine View Post
Quote:
Originally Posted by spruce View Post
Game #1, where the Jester actually won the game, but scum gained a second place finish. What do you think, is that the best way to judge it?
My opinion is no. I know that most TR players discount a jester win and only count a town or scum win. But I think that discounts the jester role.

I think we need to give jesters the wins they deserve.

This will do two things in short order.

The rest of the players will stop killing them quickly and jesters will have to get clever about it.

What does everyone else think?
Doesn't determination of victory depend on what the GM says the victory conditions are?

So, if the GM includes a jester with X victory conditions and the jester player fulfills those conditions, then that player wins a victory.

It doesn't matter what we think should be the outcomes, and it's not a matter of shoehorning this into some neat model.

If the GM says borealis's VC is to survive past N1 and also win with town, then if she does, borealis scores two distinct victories.
I agree.
Adenosine is offline   Reply With Quote topbottom
Reply

  MindRomp Forum > Community > Mafia

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 01:07 PM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2018, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Copyright 2011-2018 MindRomp.org