Food Obsession Mafia Day 3

[sparking]

Originally Posted by Mantisdreamz

mmk. I'm starting to think you are scum this game..

we are town

admittedly havent been right about much and feeling a bit lost, but that's the game

[Mantisdreamz]

Originally Posted by OmicronPersei8

I'll just let that comment speak for itself

It's hard being scum, eh op?

[Mantisdreamz]

Originally Posted by sparking

we are town

admittedly havent been right about much and feeling a bit lost, but that's the game

do you still think MZ could be scum?

[rachmarie]

Wait a min is corke really voting for himself/Jiffy???

[sparking]

Originally Posted by Mantisdreamz

do you still think MZ could be scum?

only if he killed charlou because he felt bad about fooling her or something like that

he felt more 'obvious town' to me last game, he's picked his spots more here and has been less aggressive

[spruce]

Originally Posted by rachmarie

Wait a min is corke really voting for himself/Jiffy???

no. oopsie.

Lynch:
OmicronPersei8 (3) Enso, Mantis, Mz
Majiffy/Corke (0) Mz
Mantisdreamz
sparking
rachmarie
Enso
Magicziggy

[OmicronPersei8]

Originally Posted by Mantisdreamz

It's hard being scum, eh op?

Like pulling a second traitor wave on mz then quickly backing out?

[Mantisdreamz]

Originally Posted by sparking

only if he killed charlou because he felt bad about fooling her or something like that

he felt more 'obvious town' to me last game, he's picked his spots more here and has been less aggressive

Last game was interesting though, because there were game role logistics to be figured out. So I think he was into that.

[rachmarie]

I think he would have killed char on N1 then because she knows him best of all of us, not for feeling bad about fooling her, but because he would know she could catch him even better than bor who sometimes goes back and forth especially early on as town.

[Mantisdreamz]

Originally Posted by OmicronPersei8

Like pulling a second traitor wave on mz then quickly backing out?

Not sure what you mean

[sparking]

Originally Posted by rachmarie

I think he would have killed char on N1 then because she knows him best of all of us, not for feeling bad about fooling her, but because he would know she could catch him even better than bor who sometimes goes back and forth especially early on as town.

maybe, or he could be traitor and didnt have control of the kill

mantis saying him "commenting on the book" made him less likely to be traitor, which kind of confused me cos a lot of times people who hyperfocus on that kind of stuff are just that role (and maybe signalling in their own way) "ie the old first person to talk about 3p is usually 3p" is something said a lot on forums I play on

he seemed very concerned with "finding" the traitor on d2, yet nothing really came of it, maybe he was the one being found? XD

[sparking]

eh idk

gonna chew on it

[Magicziggy]

Originally Posted by Mantisdreamz

Well, I don't think so - because can't they either recruit or kill? For instance, if they tried to kill the traitor, they would just recruit them instead. In this case, there have been kills each night.

I was assuming the role cop was also a recruit mechanism.

This needs to be sorted cos if not, then it's not lylo.

[Magicziggy]

[/quote]For purposes of this game the Town Traitor knows who are mafia but counts for parity with Town unless recruited to full mafia by either being found by the main mafia faction or targeted as a night kill by them.[/quote]

Found means role copped.

[Mantisdreamz]

Originally Posted by Magicziggy

I was assuming the role cop was also a recruit mechanism.

This needs to be sorted cos if not, then it's not lylo.

I've been thinking it is lylo! Agreed, it would be good to sort out who we all think is traitor, because it very much matters.. esp if scum don't recruit them.
I really think it is just if they target the traitor as nk.

[Mantisdreamz]

For purposes of this game the Town Traitor knows who are mafia but counts for parity with Town unless recruited to full mafia by either being found by the main mafia faction or targeted as a night kill by them.[/quote]

Found means role copped.[/QUOTE]
Oh!

[sparking]

thought experiment

enso
jiffy
mz
op8

if you had to pick one of these 4 to be town, which would you pick and why?

[sparking]

jiffy/corke* technically XD

[Mantisdreamz]

MZ - what do you think -- op8 and sparky original scum? jiffy traitor?

[rachmarie]

yeah and we have only had two nights so it would not be until tonight they could recruit I think? they would not get the result til morning anyway.

[Mantisdreamz]

Originally Posted by sparking

thought experiment

enso
jiffy
mz
op8

if you had to pick one of these 4 to be town, which would you pick and why?

this can't work. what would be the purpose of choosing from a small selection of players

[Magicziggy]

Originally Posted by OmicronPersei8

Like pulling a second traitor wave on mz then quickly backing out?

For the record I don't think there is a wave. I think jiffy just hoped his shitty play was enough.

I'm getting the vibe that Mantis is Scum .
Overnight I started second guessing myself about Charlou and she flipped town. Now I'm second guessing myself about op8 who has been a strong town read. Who's actually muddying the waters. It's sparking and Mantis.

##unvote op8##

[rachmarie]

JK is a powerful special but it is not as good as a seer/cop role unless you are down to just one scum member left then it can be used to clear someone.

[Magicziggy]

Originally Posted by Mantisdreamz

MZ - what do you think -- op8 and sparky original scum? jiffy traitor?

I'll tell you why you are scum.
Because you think jiffy is town.

[sparking]

Originally Posted by Mantisdreamz

this can't work. what would be the purpose of choosing from a small selection of players

not a matter of working, just trying to work something out

- c